The persistence probe found three silent-loss defects in the snapshot
round trip: relation validity labels (finite_sample downgraded to
heuristic after save/load!), decay configs, and the value manager's
per-relation TTL settings all vanished. The restored arbiter built its
indices directly from the condensed graph, whose edge channel carries
possibility/reliability/value only.
Format version 2 now carries per-relation metadata (validity, decayConfig)
and the valueTtls table in the snapshot payload; both the snapshot-access
layer and the CondensedGraphIndices build merge the metadata back, so a
restored arbiter is lossless end to end. Version 1 buffers are rejected
with the existing clean version error.
Pinned: a persistence round-trip test asserting validity label, decay
config, TTL, and the restored check's validity label. Suites: rigor
207/0, full 809/747/0.
Per the trust-boundary direction (the caller owns evidence validation):
- Explicit possibilistic semantics module (src/core/possibility.js): the
single authoritative home for what each operator means (max = disjunctive
already-valid; min = unvalidified conjunctive ranking with the K-
validification and surfaced conflict mass; product = Thm-4 heuristic;
interior OWA = non-maxitive heuristic; reliability = adaptation, never
conflated with plausibility).
- Provenance is opt-in (re-entrant tracing practice): default check
results carry only {label, operator, regime}; conflictMass,
validifiedPossibility, sources, and nonMaxitive appear only under
includeMeta and on the explain surface. The direct-check cache now
caches only the meta-less form — includeMeta callers always get a fresh
full evaluation (previously a cached minimal result was served for
includeMeta requests, silently stripping detail).
- Audit affordance: new Arbiter({ audit }) emits one record per check
(decision, possibility, binary, partialGraphUsed, validityLabel,
sources). The engine stores nothing — the caller owns persistence;
zero cost when the hook is absent (and the full validity is forced only
on audit-enabled deployments).
- DoS hardening: partial-graph size limits are enforced BEFORE the
context allocation (the caller-supplied overlay is the per-check
allocation point); the CondensedGraphBinary reader gained full bounds
guards so malformed snapshot buffers fail with clean errors instead of
RangeError crashes or oversized allocations.
- New security-affordance pins: gating, audit records, and pre-allocation
limits.
Adds an epistemic validity layer in the spirit of the zig-contour fusion
spec: every check result now carries a validity block {label, operator,
regime, sources, conflictMass, validifiedPossibility, nonMaxitive}.
- Relations accept a validity label (default heuristic = unlabeled input).
- Labels propagate through fusion: identity/max preserve the weakest
source label (max is already valid under arbitrary dependence); min
(conjunctive: intersection, chain, TTU, multi_hop, parent) is
approximate at best, surfaces the conflict mass (1 - possibility) that
was previously dropped, and exposes the arbitrary-regime validification
min(1, K*gamma); product-style operators (exclusion, defeasible) and
interior OWA averaging are always heuristic, with nonMaxitive flagged.
- Reliability and validity are now explicitly distinct: reliability stays
the scalar confidence adaptation; validity tracks the epistemic label.
- The hottest paths attach a shared frozen default block instead of
allocating (perf A/B shows no regression: ~300k ops/s direct both ways).
- Pre-existing fixes surfaced while wiring: the array-form logical config
dropped top-level aggregator/owaWeights (average union compiled as max),
and _createStandardResult dropped unknown fields (validity never
survived rule results).
New campaign validity-parity.test.js pins the label taxonomy, conflict
mass, validification, weakest-propagation, and the reliability/validity
separation. Suites: rigor 203/0, full 803/741/0.
John Dvorak