# @arbiter/value-graph The "second graph": a graph-structured, lazy, TTL + version-invalidated store of derived values, built on `@push-stream-std`. The authorization graph (`@arbiter/core`) stores structural edges with possibility; the value graph stores **value relations** computed lazily on demand — the substrate for DSL `measure` lookups and ARRA balances. ## Node operator model Each value relation is an **operator node** with `parents` (its `dependsOn`): | Operator | Kind | Behavior | |----------|------|----------| | `source` | leaf | external value via `fn(subject, params, ctx, cb)` (e.g. ARRA) | | `attribute` | leaf | reads a graph node field via `resolveAttribute(nodeKey, path, params, ctx, cb)` | | `pattern` | leaf | graph-traversal value via `resolvePattern(pattern, subject, params, ctx, cb)` | | `compute` | interior | `fn(subject, params, ctx, cb)` over parent values (`ctx.deps`) | | `blackbox` | interior | general function of its dependencies — `fn(subject, params, ctx, cb)` with `ctx.deps` (parent values) and `ctx.entries` (full parent results `{ value, unit, at, source, fresh }`). The seam for composing an external (e.g. Overlay) query from parent edges/values | | `fusion:` | interior | combines parent values by an OWA operator | ## Callback resolver contract (no async/await/promises) Every resolver — `source`/`compute` `fn`, `resolveAttribute`, `resolvePattern` — is **callback oriented**, matching the push-stream discipline of `@overlay` adapters. A resolver MUST either: 1. call `cb(err, result)` asynchronously and return `undefined`, or 2. return the result synchronously (pure compute / memoized reads). `result` may be a value, `{ value, unit, source }`, an interval `{ lower, upper }`, or `null`/`undefined` (→ uncached `null`). Returning a **Promise is rejected** with a descriptive error — this library is promise-free. This contract is what lets the future `value-graph-overlay` bridge implement resolvers over Overlay's callback/push-stream `FederatedQueryEngine`. ### Black-box nodes A `blackbox` node is an arbitrary function of its resolved dependencies. Inside the resolver, `ctx.deps[parent]` is the parent's **value**, and `ctx.entries[parent]` is the parent's **full result** (`{ value, unit, at, source, fresh }`). Use it to compose an external query from the parent edges/values — e.g. key an Overlay query off a `pattern` parent's edge set: ```js vg.define('risk', { operator: 'blackbox', parents: ['related_edges', 'base_balance'], fn: (subject, params, ctx, cb) => { const edges = ctx.deps.related_edges; // array of edges from the pattern node const balance = ctx.entries.base_balance; // full { value, unit, at, source, fresh } overlayQuery(buildAst(subject, edges, balance), cb); // callback-based, no promises } }); ``` **OWA fusion operators** (ADR-000): `max`, `min`, `average`, `sum` (capped 1.0), `sum_unbounded`, `majority`, `median`, `optimistic`, `pessimistic`, `top2`, `top3`, `priority`, `custom` (user weights), `product`. Numeric values use position-based weights over descending order; non-numeric values fall back to `max`/`min`/`majority`. ## Compile → optimize → run (never fused) - `plan(subject, relation, params)` walks `parents` into a node DAG and OPTIMIZES it (compile and optimize are one call; the graph is deliberately **never fused** — each operator stays a separately-cacheable node): - **Cached-subtree pruning** — a cache-safe (fresh) node becomes a **single trivial leaf with no parents**, pruning its dependency subtree, so `run()` reads its cache instead of re-evaluating. - **Ghost-parent elimination** — a fusion parent that is undeclared AND uncached is guaranteed `null`, which fusion filters anyway; it is dropped at compile time to avoid a wasted node evaluation. (Not applied to compute/blackbox, which receive `null` in deps and may handle it.) - Plan metadata: `size`, `recomputeCount` (nodes `run()` evaluates), `prunedCount` (nodes served from cache), `ghostPruned` (dropped ghosts). - `run(plan, cb)` evaluates the DAG in dependency order, dispatching each node to its operator and caching the result — all callback-driven, no promises. **Parallelism**: all independent parents are fired as soon as they are reached (one synchronous pass starts every resolver), so N independent async resolvers (e.g. Overlay REST calls) are in flight simultaneously — verified by test (max in-flight === N). A node reachable via multiple paths (a diamond/shared subtree) is evaluated **exactly once per run**: later paths join the in-flight evaluation via waiter fan-out instead of re-firing the resolver (this fixed a real double-firing bug for async resolvers). **Race safety**: a run only caches its results if no `set`/`invalidate` occurred mid-run (run-epoch guard) — a slow read can never clobber an authoritative `set`, and a pre-mutation snapshot is never cached after an `invalidate` (both fixed + rigor-verified). - `invalidate(subject, relation, params)` requires the relation — calling it with only a subject now throws instead of silently clearing the whole store (`invalidate()` with no args still clears everything). - `invalidate`/`set` compile the **affected dependent DAG** (the relation plus every transitive dependent), push `{ stale: true }` triggers DOWN to active queries (both notify the affected relation's own watchers; `set` marks the set relation's trigger with no `via`, dependents with `via`), and bump **per-relation version stamps** — so invalidation is **selective**: only the affected closure recomputes; unrelated relations keep their cached entries (verified by js-rigor). ## Pull on duplex push `query(subject, relation, params)` returns a duplex: push `{ get: true }` up (compile + run, serialized), receive the value down. External sources push `invalidate`/`set` to send back-channel stale triggers. ## Backing store & larger-than-memory The graph object itself holds only its **schema** (`relations` — the operator definitions) and **active streams**; every cached entry lives in the swappable backing store (`get`/`set`/`delete`/`clear`/`keys`/`deletePrefix`). That is what makes the value graph **larger-than-memory** — data volume is decoupled from RAM, exactly the posture of the auth graph (`@arbiter/core`'s condensed typed-array graph + planned sharded snapshots, ADR-003). - `createMapStore()` — in-memory default (a `Map`). - `createFileStore(dir, { maxResident })` — disk-backed reference: one **binary** file per entry (the same JSON-free wire encoding the snapshots use), with a bounded LRU **hot-page cache** on top. A fresh `ValueGraph` pointed at the same directory reads cached values straight from disk without recompute — proven by test. **No JSON, no JS bigint** on disk — large integers are `Uint8Array`. - Any store implementing the synchronous contract is swappable — an mmap-backed store, a remote catalog, or (later) an Overlay-backed store. ```js import { ValueGraph, createFileStore } from '@arbiter/value-graph'; const vg = new ValueGraph({ store: createFileStore('./vg-data', { maxResident: 256 }) }); ``` ### Compact snapshots, read from disk, transportable A snapshot is a **single compact, CRC-guarded binary file** — no paths, no machine-dependent encoding, **no JSON and no JS bigint on the wire** (large integers are raw `Uint8Array` bytes; params/pattern/objects are deterministic binary maps) — so a graph moves between processes and machines byte-for-byte. Two flavours share one wire format: - **Store snapshot** — opaque `key → entry` dump of the backing store. `store.snapshotFile(path)` / `store.restoreFile(path)` on both store flavours; `createFileStore(dir, { loadFrom })` constructs a store already loaded from a snapshot. - **Graph snapshot** — the seamless artifact: **schema metadata** (operator, parents, weights, TTL, returnType, params — minus functions) **+ every entry**. ```js vg.snapshotFile('./graph.snap'); // stream to disk, bounded memory const buf = vg.snapshot(); // or a portable Buffer const vg2 = ValueGraph.restore(buf, { resolvers: { balance: () => loadBalance() } }); const vg3 = ValueGraph.loadFile('./graph.snap', { resolvers: { balance: () => loadBalance() } }); ``` `restore`/`loadFile` re-declare the schema and load entries with their version re-stamped, so a restored cache is served **without recompute** (subject to TTL — old snapshots expire on the wall-clock like any other entry). Functions cannot be serialized: re-register resolvers via `{ resolvers }`. A corrupt or truncated snapshot **throws** (magic/version/CRC/parse guards) — it never silently mis-reads. ## Typed values (DSL-declared schema) The graph carries **schema metadata** from the evidence DSL: `define(rel, { returnType, params })` records the declared return type (a primitive like `number`/`string`/`boolean`/`buffer`/ `timestamp`/`array`/`interval`, or an entity/Definition name treated as a reference key) and parameter types. `relationSpec(rel)` introspects it. **There is no JS `bigint` type** — large integers are `buffer` (`Uint8Array`), matching the JSON-free wire. - `set(...)` validates the value against `returnType` (untyped relations are backward-compatible and skip validation). - Resolver results are validated against `returnType` too — a wrong-typed resolver fails loudly instead of caching garbage. - **`NaN` is rejected** at both the `set` and resolver-result boundaries — it is not a meaningful derived value and would poison downstream OWA. - `validateValueType(value, type)` is exported for consumers (the DSLValueGraph integration uses it for binding + value checks). This is the storage/typing substrate for `DSLValueGraph` in `@arbiter/evidence-dsl`: measures declared in the DSL become typed value-graph nodes; attributes that are neither cached nor computed are stored via `setValue`; `measure()`/`runtime.measure()` retrieve through the graph. ## Example ```js import { ValueGraph } from '@arbiter/value-graph'; const vg = new ValueGraph({ resolveAttribute: (nodeKey, path, params, ctx, cb) => cb(null, graphNodes.get(nodeKey)?.[path]) }); vg.define('base_balance', { operator: 'source', fn: (s, p, ctx, cb) => cb(null, ledgerBalance(s)) }); vg.define('risk_adjusted', { operator: 'compute', parents: ['base_balance'], fn: (s, p, { deps }) => deps.base_balance * 0.9 }); vg.define('effective_clearance', { operator: 'fusion:max', parents: ['base', 'role', 'group'] }); vg.define('avg_score', { operator: 'fusion:custom', parents: ['rep', 'activity', 'verif'], weights: [0.6, 0.3, 0.1] }); const plan = vg.plan('tenant:acme', 'risk_adjusted', {}); vg.run(plan, (err, value) => { /* { value, unit, at, source, fresh } */ }); ``` ## Deep testing (js-rigor) `test/value-graph.rigor.test.js` (`npm run test:rigor`) is a js-rigor suite: - **OWA properties** — `owa`/`weightFor` invariants (sum/avg/max/min/median/top2/ product/optimistic/pessimistic/custom, string fallbacks) + a `sum` oracle. This caught and fixed two real edge cases: `weightFor('top2'|'top3', n)` over-produced weight vectors for `n` smaller than the named positions, and `weightFor(op, 0)` returned `[1]` for `max`/`min` instead of `[]`. - **OWA oracle conformance** — an *independent* reimplementation of the ADR-000 OWA formula (`refOwaExact`, mirrored arithmetic for bit-exact `===`) confirms every operator: exact oracles for sum/max/min/product/median/string fallbacks + capped sum, and **arbitrary operator combinations** (a frequency-weighted pick over all 14 operators × random arrays × random weights/priorities) must match the reference. - **Fusion DAG oracles** — the graph's fusion path must equal raw `owa` for any operator, and **composed DAGs** (fusion-of-fusion, compute→fusion chains) must equal the bottom-up reference over the same operators. - **More correctness oracles** — mixed fusion+compute topologies vs the bottom-up reference; **invalidation correctness** (changing a source and invalidating it yields the correct new root value across the dependent subtree); **cache-key isolation** (subjects never share entries, each computes once); **stale-on-error fallback** (a failing resolver after TTL expiry returns the cached value with `fresh:false` instead of erroring); **value-type round-trips** (array/interval/ buffer survive the disk-backed store into a fresh graph instance); **blackbox over fusion** (`fusion(a,b)·k` matches the reference); and **selective invalidation** (invalidating/setting an unrelated relation leaves its cached entry untouched; a sibling independent subtree stays cached). - **Universal invariants** — for *every* operator: empty→`0`, singleton→element, sum/sum_unbounded/product exact, weighted operators bounded within `[min,max]`, and monotone non-decreasing under a `+1` bump. Plus: **plan exactness** (fully-cached plan is one leaf; invalidation expands to exactly the affected closure with unrelated leaves still trivial); **async serialization** (two concurrent `{get}` pushes with an async resolver deliver both values and the second is served from cache — resolver called once); **params cache-key isolation**; **cross-subject invalidation correctness**; **invalidateAll clears every subject**; **ghost parents are filtered from fusions**; **attribute/ pattern hooks receive the documented arguments**; **TTL boundary is exact** (fresh inside, stale at the window, `ttl:0` never expires); **`set` preserves unit/source**; in-graph string fusion fallbacks + `capSum`; and **duplicate parents are a single dependency** (parents are a set). - **Random-topology DAG oracles** — three mid fusion nodes over randomly-picked source pairs plus a root fusion, all with random operators, must match the independent bottom-up reference (`refOwaExact`), including the duplicate-parent set semantics. - **Complexity verification** — `run()` on a deep compute chain is `O(n)` resolver calls (no recomputation blowup), `plan()` compiles a deep chain in `O(n)`, and `weightFor` allocates `O(n)` weights (deterministic cost metrics). - **Compile-time optimization** — ghost parents are eliminated at compile time (semantics preserved for every operator vs `refOwaExact`), a fully-cached plan is a single trivial leaf with zero recomputes, and an invalidated plan recomputes exactly the affected closure while serving the untouched sibling from cache. - **Graph caching model (formal conformance)** — `rigor.model.check` runs random `get`/`set`/`invalidate`/`mutate` sequences against a reference model of the per-relation-version caching contract and the real graph; every value must match. Pins the exact semantics: `set` writes fresh without bumping the relation version, `invalidate` bumps it and recomputes, and a backing mutation without invalidation stays cached until the next invalidation/TTL. - **Query duplex lifecycle** — a randomized `get`/`invalidate` stream delivers only correct values and well-formed stale triggers; `end()` cleans up so post-end writes are silent no-ops (including `invalidate` pushes to the closed query); and `abort()` surfaces its error on the stream. - **Store-fault robustness** — a throwing store must never hang or crash the graph: a store whose `set` always fails still serves correct values (best-effort uncached serve — this fixed a real hang where a run-time `store.set` failure was swallowed by the resolver guard), a flaky store recovers (later gets are cached), and a store whose `get` fails surfaces the error via callback. The universal OWA invariants also pin the constant-array case (all-equal inputs → the value for weighted operators). - **Algebraic OWA invariants** — results are **invariant under input order** (any operator: sort-based), and **max/min/average/median are invariant under multiset duplication** (each element duplicated; FP-tolerance for average). - **Params-scoped invalidation & CSE** — invalidating one params set deletes that key while every subject/params value stays correct; a **shared subtree** in a diamond DAG is computed once across two roots and once across the post- invalidation recompute (no redundant evaluation); and `invalidate` clears an eager `set` value so the next get recomputes from the resolver. - **Action-level fault injection** — under injected `rigor.faults` (throw on the get action) the callback contract still holds: correct value or surfaced error, never a hang. - **Parallel firing & async CSE** — N independent async resolvers fire simultaneously (max in-flight === N), each exactly once; a diamond DAG with async resolvers fires its shared node exactly once (no duplicate REST calls); and waiter fan-out joins at every level of a deep shared subtree. - **Stateful protocol, concurrency, edges, benchmark** — a `rigor.object` protocol campaign (with `before`/`after`/`between`) pins "after `set(v)` every `get` returns `v` until `invalidate`"; **concurrent direct gets** on one graph each complete independently and correctly (N calls for N gets, no torn state); a run error inside a query duplex is pushed down as `{ error }`; `set` rejects unsupported value shapes; resolvers propagate `{ value, unit, source }` onto the delivered entry; and a loose **latency benchmark** smoke guards the fast path. - **Graph semantics** — caching (second get computes nothing), invalidation cascade, `set` override, plan pruning, TTL expiry, `blackbox` deps/entries. - **Callback contract** — handler-based: sync + async resolver delivery, resolver error propagation, Promise-return rejection, duplex pull (two gets), and stale trigger pushed between values on `invalidate`. - **Store contract** — model-based conformance (`rigor.model.check`) of `createMapStore` and `createFileStore` against a reference `Map` under random `set`/`get`/`delete`/`clear`/`deletePrefix` sequences. ## License ISC